Comparison

Gusto PTO Tracking: When It's Enough, and When to Use a Separate Tool

Gusto is payroll software with PTO built in. Here's when Gusto's time off is all you need, and when a dedicated time-off tracker makes more sense.

TS
The SimplyPTO Team
Nov 16, 2026 · 4 min read
SimplyPTO

Gusto is payroll software that a lot of small US businesses already use, and it includes time off. So the honest starting point is this: if you already run payroll in Gusto and its PTO features cover your policy, you may not need anything else.

This page is for the other cases: you're not on Gusto, you're considering it mainly for time off, or you want more around time off than payroll software is built to give.

What Gusto costs

From Gusto's pricing page (checked November 2026):

PlanPriceTime off
Simple$49 a month + $7 per person"Basic PTO policies and holiday pay"
Plus$99 a month + $12 per personAdds time tracking and scheduling
Premium$179 a month + $22 per personAdds HR guidance and compliance tools

For an 8-person team on Simple, that's $49 + $56 = $105 a month. That's good value if you need payroll. It's a lot if you only need time off.

What a time-off tool costs

SimplyPTO only does time off, with every feature on every plan:

Team sizeSimplyPTO
Up to 10 peopleFree
Up to 20 people$9 a month
Up to 50 people$19 a month
Up to 100 people$29 a month

The same 8-person team pays nothing.

Cost as your team grows

Monthly list prices on Gusto Simple (checked November 2026), next to SimplyPTO:

Team sizeGusto SimpleSimplyPTO
5 people$84Free
15 people$154$9
25 people$224$19
40 people$329$19

That's not a fair comparison if you need payroll, because Gusto runs payroll and SimplyPTO doesn't. It's the right comparison if time off is the reason you're looking.

Check whether Gusto's "basic PTO" covers your policy

Before you decide Gusto's time off is enough, check it against your actual rules, not a feature list:

  • Accrual: do people earn time per pay period, per month or per hour worked? Does it handle the one you use?
  • Carryover: is there a cap on unused days rolling into next year, and does it match yours?
  • Half days: can people book half a day?
  • Company holidays: do they come off the calendar without touching anyone's balance?
  • Visibility: can everyone see who else is off before they ask?
  • Approvals: who approves, and what happens when that person is away?

If you answer "no" or "not sure" to two or more, a dedicated tool will save you workarounds.

Which one you need

Stay with Gusto's time off if:

  • You already run payroll in Gusto, and
  • Its PTO policies match your rules (accrual, carryover, holidays), and
  • You don't need much beyond balances being right on payslips.

Use a separate time-off tool if:

  • You don't need payroll software, or run payroll somewhere else. Paying per person for payroll just to track leave doesn't add up.
  • You want everyone to see who's off. A shared team calendar, so people plan around each other before they ask.
  • You want to approve time off your way. Approve every request yourself, or let time off go straight on the calendar unless someone else is already off that day.
  • Your team works in Slack or Google Calendar. Requests and "who's out today" in Slack, and approved time off on each person's own calendar.

Using both

JobWhere it lives
Paychecks, taxes, benefitsGusto
Booking and approving time offTime-off tool
Who's off this weekTime-off tool (shared calendar)
Balances and carryoverTime-off tool
Time off on payslipsGusto, from the time-off export

Many teams keep payroll in Gusto and run time off in a separate tool. It works well because the jobs are different:

  1. People book time off on the shared calendar, and you approve it.
  2. Balances update on their own, including carryover and company holidays.
  3. At payroll time, export the time-off records and enter what payroll needs.

What payroll needs from your time-off records

If time off lives in one tool and payroll in another, the handoff only has to carry a few things each pay period:

  • Who was off, and on which dates inside the pay period, not just the request dates.
  • Paid or unpaid. Unpaid leave usually changes pay; paid time off usually doesn't.
  • Half days, counted as 0.5 rather than rounded.
  • Anything that changed after approval, like a cancelled day or new dates.

An export filtered to the pay period gives you all four. Most small teams find it takes a few minutes per payroll run, which is far less than keeping a spreadsheet in step with Gusto by hand.

Getting started

Add your team by name or import your spreadsheet. Nobody needs an account until you invite them, and you can record their time off yourself in the meantime. Under 10 people it's free, with no card and no trial clock.

Related: how to choose PTO software for a small business, five ways to track PTO compared, and BambooHR and Vacation Tracker compared.

Frequently asked questions

Does Gusto track PTO?

Yes. Gusto's Simple plan lists 'basic PTO policies and holiday pay' among its features, so time off is tied to payroll from the cheapest plan. Check what 'basic' covers for your policy before relying on it.

How much does Gusto cost?

On Gusto's pricing page (checked November 2026), Simple is $49 a month plus $7 per person, Plus is $99 a month plus $12 per person, and Premium is $179 a month plus $22 per person. Time tracking and scheduling start on Plus.

Should I pay for Gusto just to track time off?

Usually not. Gusto is priced as payroll software. If you run payroll elsewhere, or don't need payroll at all, paying $49 a month plus $7 per person only to track time off is expensive. A dedicated time-off tool is free or a few dollars a month at small team sizes.

Can I use Gusto for payroll and a separate tool for time off?

Yes, and plenty of small teams do. Keep payroll in Gusto, use a time-off tool for requests, approvals and the shared calendar, and export the records for payroll when you need them.

Related in Small Business HR

Stop tracking PTO in a spreadsheet

SimplyPTO tracks balances, requests, and approvals automatically — with a shared team calendar. Free for up to 10 people, no credit card.

Get started free →